While we love treating ourselves to luxurious beauty products and treatments from time to time, we also balance it out with some drugstore beauty modesty. We have tested out many different drugstore beauty products and found some of our must-haves and will-never-give-up products. Take a peek at some of our favorite, underrated drugstore beauty products.

Sonia Kashuk Luminosity Highlighter Stick
Who says highlighter has to cost upwards of $30? This highlighter stick is a favorite as it gives your skin a nice, dewy glow where ever applied and lasts a long, long time! It’s safe to say we go through maybe two of these a year. Target, $11.

Maybelline Lasting Drama Waterproof Gel Pencil

We’ve tried out a fair share of eyeliners–all types–and this waterproof gel eyeliner by Maybelline comes out on top. It will last all day and all night, literally. You can make it as subtle or as dramatic as you want. Walmart, $7.

 
L’Oreal Voluminous Superstar Waterproof Mascara
Make your lashes pop with this mascara that delivers maximum volume. The first application is to prime and extend your lashes and the second step is a fiber-rich formula that dramatizes them. Amazon, $8.
 
Essie Gel Setter Top Coat
Forget chipped nails! Adding a coat of this gel setter top coat by Essie will give your freshly-painted nails a longer and chip-free life. While it’s called a gel setter top coat, this also works well on regular nail polish. Target, $10.
 
NYX Butter Gloss 
This gloss goes on exactly how it’s described…like butter. Not to mention these glosses don’t dry out our lips out and come in a variety of shades featuring lots of nude shades and light pinks. One of our must-have shades in Fortune Cookie, which delivers a soft, peachy nude look.  CVS, $5.